Two twin brothers discover that forgiveness can be a powerful form of revenge when one is framed for murder, and the other fights to regain his innocent sibling's freedom. High school seniors Pete and Maggie were planning to get married when Maggie was murdered by a jealous romantic rival. When all evidence points to aspiring preacher Pete as the killer, he is left to suffer in prison while the real killer walks free. Meanwhile, Pete's reckless brother Andy begins a tireless campaign for justice. But just when it seems as if the two siblings are poised to seek vengeance, an unusual course of events reveals that grace is the only true path to healing.